Thursday, 19 November 2026

Inspirations: Twice Upon A Time


Feeling obliged to write a Christmas Special after Chris Chibnall stated that he was not ready to launch the Thirteenth Doctor until the Spring of 2018, Steven Moffat had to look at what festive elements had still to be used in the series - though he had already claimed that they had pretty much run out of the obvious Christmas trappings which might be exploited for a storyline.
The episode would have to tie up the Twelfth Doctor's story, and bring his own tenure as showrunner to a close. 
The groundwork for the regeneration had already been laid by having the Twelfth meet the First Doctor at the conclusion of The Doctor Falls, setting this in Antarctica during the latter stages of The Tenth Planet. Both were facing their regenerations, and both were stubbornly refusing to allow the process to go ahead. Over the course of events in this episode, each would help the other come to terms with what was about to happen.
It was noted that whenever previous incarnations of the Doctor met up they often clashed, which might allow for some humorous interplay between the pair.
Moffat was also thinking of the classic festive movie It's A Wonderful Life (1946) in which James Stewart plays a man who is given a chance to see what life would be like had he taken a certain course of action, and not unlike the future presented by the Ghost of Christmas-Yet-To-Come in Dickens' A Christmas Carol.

Looking at events in history set in the festive period, Moffat recalled the Christmas Truce during the first winter of the Great War. This event had been popularised by the video for Paul McCartney's 1983 song Pipes of Peace.
Moffat had been considering using it as the backdrop to a story for some time, but was wary of trivialising an incident from the Great War.
Famously, it had always been claimed through the Autumn and early Winter of 1914 that this conflict would be over by Christmas. In December of that year, the end was nowhere in sight.
Following the indecisive first Battle of Ypres, and the failure of the German "Race to the Sea" offensive, soldiers on both sides elected to cease hostilities for a short time. On Christmas Eve, it was agreed that bodies could be retrieved from No Man's Land for burial and prisoner swaps were arranged. In some cases football matches were organised and opposing armies mingled and ate together before singing Christmas carols.

Knowing that this was to be his last story in charge, Moffat wrote a part specifically for his Sherlock collaborator Mark Gatiss. He would play a British officer involved in the Christmas Truce, who would prove to be a forebear of Brigadier Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart, thus showing that that the Doctor had a greater role to play in the family which had come to mean so much to him. Gatiss would play the Brigadier's grandfather, Captain Archibald Hamish Lethbridge-Stewart.
He would find himself trapped in a foxhole with a wounded German soldier - and this allowed for the casting of another old friend of Moffat's - one who, like Gatiss, was also a writer. After writing School Reunion for RTD, Toby Whithouse had contributed six episodes throughout Moffat's tenure, most recently The Lie of the Land, and he was cast as the German soldier.
The Captain later states that he lives in Cromer in Norfolk - a reference to Nicholas Courtney's famous ad-libbed line in The Three Doctors.

The First Doctor we see here isn't quite the one as portrayed by William Hartnell. Rather, it is more of a caricature based partly on his character and that of Hartnell himself. For many years cast and crew had been generally positive about working with the actor - giving a sanitised version of their experience. 
But then Anneke Wills returned to the UK and began attending conventions. She was far more open about the negative experience she had of working with Hartnell, warts and all.
There's no real hint of the actor's racism here, though this is a more sexist and patronising version of the First Doctor. He is presented more as an old-fashioned fuddy-duddy.
At one point he threatens Bill with a jolly good smacked bottom - a First Doctor line to Susan from The Dalek Invasion of Earth.
David Bradley's iteration of the Doctor would be introduced by morphing his features over footage of Hartnell from The Tenth Planet's second episode.
Cut from the broadcast episode were more recreated scenes from The Tenth Planet, including a reprise for the Mondasian Cyberman costumes created for World Enough And Time / The Doctor Falls.
Ben and Polly feature - though the actor playing the former is rather too tall.
(These deleted scenes can be viewed on the DVD).
The first draft script had Ben and Polly later married and running a pub (as Michael Craze had really done) but RTD had already claimed they were running an orphanage in India in The Sarah Jane Adventures.

The enemy for the special - Testimony - would actually prove to be a benign entity, so for a genuine threat Moffat returned to "Rusty", the Dalek-hating Dalek introduced in Into The Dalek, right at the start of Capaldi's tenure. Daleks were usually outlawed from festive specials as they inevitably meant mass death and destruction, which isn't what families necessarily wanted served to them on Christmas evening. Rusty only really wanted to destroy other Daleks, however.
In showing the First Doctor what he later will become, clips from earlier stories were shown by Testimony, including Davros taunting the Tenth Doctor.
Rusty turns up on Villengard - a planet first mentioned in Moffat's very first story for Doctor Who. Its weapons forges are talked about in The Doctor Dances - Captain Jack saying that he got his squareness gun there, only for the Doctor to imply that he destroyed the factories as they are now covered in banana groves.
The Doctor seeks out Rusty in order to access its database and find out what Testimony actually is.
Testimony is said to have been founded on New Earth, a world first introduced in the story of that name in 2006 and revisited in Gridlock the following year.

As the story revolved around the act of witnessing, Moffat wanted someone to witness the Doctor's actions at the end of his current life, and decided that he wanted this to be Bill Potts. As Testimony could take on other people's likenesses, this allowed her to return since Bill had left behind her physical existence as a Cyberman at the end of The Doctor Falls to go travelling with Heather.
The final thing Moffat wanted to include was the Doctor regaining his memories of Clara, and Jenna Coleman was contacted whilst working on the second series of Victoria. She promised to make herself available, though it might only be for a couple of hours.
Matt Lucas would also return as Nardole for a final apearance.

The closing section was left for Chris Chibnall to write. He originally intended only for the new Doctor's POV to be seen until the very last moment, before she fell out of the TARDIS doors.
Capaldi's final scene was also the Twelfth Doctor's final scene. On the last day of shooting, Gatiss brought along to the studio the jacket which Jon Pertwee had worn in Planet of the Daleks, which Capaldi tried on. It was left on set in the background during the regeneration sequence.
Next time: The women who fall to Earth. The new Doctor encounters an alien who doesn't need to argue to go blue in the face...

No comments:

Post a Comment