Sunday, 22 November 2026

Episode 233: The Seeds of Death (2)


Synopsis:
Slaar calls for a guard and orders it to kill technician Locke, who has been attempting to warn T-Mat Control on Earth about the invaders.
An Ice Warrior enters, and shoots him dead...
Phipps manages to run off, and Slaar orders the Warriors to hunt him down before accusing Fewsham of contacting Earth. He denies aiding his colleagues, claiming he did not know what they were going to do. He is told to repair the emergency T-Mat link with Earth or die.
In Eldred's museum, the old man is still proving reluctant to help and claims that his rocket needs too much work to complete.
Jamie asks the Doctor if they could not use the TARDIS, but he replies that it isn't terribly reliable for short trips. He then proposes that he could pilot the rocket, as Eldred has already pointed out that he is too old to survive a lift-off.
On hearing an update about food shortages, Radnor puts his foot down and orders the go-ahead for the rocket anyway.
Phipps is hiding in the Solar Energy Store, having managed to evade the searching Ice Warriors. He begins to put together a solar amplifier device.
Following a conference it has been agreed that the Doctor will pilot the rocket, accompanied by Zoe. Both have impressed with their knowledge of space travel. Gia Kelly insists on taking the third crew place - but Radnor demands that she remain at T-Mat Control. Jamie refuses to be left behind, and will go with his friends.
The rocket will only have enough fuel to get them to the Moon, where automated systems will refuel it - though the Doctor is confident that they will be able to repair T-Mat and use that to return to Earth.
As Fewsham works on the emergency link, he points out that the system can only take a couple of people at a time, and would therefore be of no use to an invading army. Slaar replies that they will not need an army, as Earth will be theirs for the taking...
Mission control is set up at the museum and rocket ZA-685 soon blasts off.
However, a fault on board causes mission control to lose all radio communications with the rocket.
Fewsham reports to Slaar that his repairs are complete, and the warlord instructs him to set the system to 'receive' only.
This is flagged up by Brent at T-Mat Control. Gia arranges for herself and a couple of technicians to travel to Moonbase to sort out the problems personally. When Radnor tries to stop her, she threatens to go over his head.
In the solar energy store, Phipps has rigged up a makeshift weapon using infra-red reflectors attached to the solar amplifier.
When Gia and the technicians arrive at Moonbase, they find only Fewsham present. He claims that Osgood went mad and killed the others before going outside without a spacesuit. She turns off T-Mat until a full diagnostic can be run - and to prevent Radnor from sending anyone to fetch her back to Earth.
Concealed, Slaar is listening in. He orders his Warriors to continue their search for Phipps.
He, meanwhile, is trying to contact Earth with a radio transmitter.
In the rocket, the Doctor explains to his companions that they must now activate an automated homing device, which will guide them to the Moonbase landing pad.
Phipps' attempts to call Earth are overheard by an Ice Warrior. Hearing it approach, he hurriedly unplugs the transmitter and replaces it with his solar energy weapon. When the Warrior enters the room, he activates this and the creature is destroyed.
However, in swapping the equipment around he has accidentally deactivated the homing beacon.
As the Doctor struggles to get the signal back, Jamie asks if they are going to crash.
Zoe tells him that it will either be that, or they will drift on endlessly through space...

Data:
Written by Brian Hayles
Recorded: Friday 10th January 1969
First broadcast: 5.15pm, Saturday 1st February 1969
Ratings: 6.8 million / AI 59
VFX: Bill King and Trading Post 
Designer: Peter Allen
Director: Michael Ferguson 
Additional cast: Tony Harwood (Ice Warrior)


Critique:
This is the last of the six episodes which can be said to be mostly the work of Brian Hayles, though Terrance Dicks has reworked some of the material.
In the first version of this episode, after Slaar had secured the Moonbase, he was joined by a superior named Visek.
Radnor actually had Eldred locked up due to his refusal to allow his rocket to be used, until the Doctor eventually persuaded him to co-operate.
The professor joined the Doctor and his companions on the rocket mission, and they discovered after launching that Mary Burcott, T-Mat's PR Officer, had stowed away onboard.
Phipps destroyed the searching Ice Warrior by electrocuting it. Fewsham later hid with him in the storeroom and the pair argued about contacting Earth at the episode's conclusion. 
In these earlier drafts, Fewsham was less of a coward and more a willing collaborator with the Ice Warriors.

It was decided that the Warriors' appearance should be more consistent, and as such only those helmets previously worn by the likes of Varga and Zondal in The Ice Warriors would be used. The Martians would also be of uniform stature. In their first appearance, three different helmet designs had been used, and some of the Warriors were noticeably shorter than others.
Cast as Slaar, Alan Bennion would wear a more streamlined one-piece costume made of neoprene rubber. The only armour he sported was a breastplate and a tall bullet-shaped helmet. These, and the clamp-like hands, were constructed by Jack and John Lovell.
The Perspex eye panels were backed with gauze and coated with an orange gel to ensure that the actor's eyes could not be seen. It was found that the gel flared under the studio lights and so they were sprayed with a substance to make them less reflective. This had the unfortunate effect of Bennion being rendered virtually blind once the helmet was on and he would need to be guided around the set. Slaar only ever appears in the Moonbase control room, so he was soon able to get used to the layout.
Unable to see visual cues, an out of shot studio assistant would tap him on the back of the leg as a signal.
John Friedlander created a latex half-mask to cover the actor's mouth area and so give a scaly reptilian appearance, and parts of his teeth were blacked out with enamel to make them look more fang-like. Bennion was slightly disappointed as he had just had expensive dental work done to polish them up.
(I love the way he kept his tie on during the make-up session - very BBC).


Filming for this episode comprised only model work, carried out at Ealing on Friday 20th and Monday 23rd December - the latter being an additional production day and the last before the team broke for Christmas.
A single model of the rocket launching area was built by Bill King's company to Peter Allen's design, which could be used as both the Earth launch pad and the Moonbase's.
This entailed simply replacing the back projection and filming it from two different angles. The large model landscape had a lunar landscape with Moonbase buildings and craters on one side, and a terrestrial setting with small trees on the other.
The ZA-685 model was four feet in length, and could either be hung on wires for scenes of it in flight, or operated by an armature hidden from view to the rear of the model for when it took off and landed.
Smoke could be piped through it for the launch sequence.


Whilst Alan Bennion was fitted with a radio microphone to pick up his dialogue, Tony Harwood had to pre-record his speech in advance of studio recording as the heavy rubber mouthpiece he wore made speaking difficult.
For the opening credits, the Earth / Moon model shot was reversed from the first episode.
Recording took place in story order initially, but all of the solar energy storeroom scenes were filmed together in a single block.
The attack on the Ice Warrior was simply achieved through rapid intercutting of the output of two cameras pointing at Harwood, and switching the image in and out of negative. A recording break then allowed Harwood to exit the set, to be replaced by a puddle of liquid on the floor.
It was during these storeroom scenes that Wendy Padbury changed outfit. As the costume budget was tight, it had been agreed in advance that she would contribute towards the cost of the costume - a trouser suit made from yellow leather - and then be able to keep it for herself afterwards.
A black circular mask was used for the mission control sequence, recorded on the museum set with the lights dimmed. The director cut from the actors to photo captions of various scientific instruments, accompanied by a distinctive "finger-clicking" sound. Ferguson added some visual interest by having the countdown numbers projected onto Louise Pajo's face.
The rocket launch included some stock footage from a Soviet documentary film.
The end credits began to run over footage of the rocket model in space.

A few cuts were made to the episode for timing reasons. One of these was a dialogue scene between two Ice Warriors, explaining why there were so few people in the Moonbase.
Another sequence lost was the start of a museum scene. The Doctor and his companions stood by and watched as technicians set up the mission control equipment, whilst Kelly ran checks and Eldred and Radnor discussed getting fuel out to the rocket.

The first cut scene has one of the Ice Warriors state that most of the base's rooms are empty as they are now disused. With Earth totally reliant on T-Mat now, and regular space travel consigned to history, then the base would no longer be used the way it was before. T-Mat would only require a handful of technicians to oversee it. Viewers at home would have been wondering why such a large base had so few people in it. (The one in The Moonbase was said to have a staff of 19. There is nothing on screen to suggest that this is the same place).
Dicks' idea to have the leader of the Ice Warriors a more humanoid figure is certainly a very good one. Try and imagine this story with a figure like Varga in command, and it doesn't work quite so well.
The interplay between the coldly calculating Slaar and the nervy, twitching Fewsham is one of the things people remember about this story.
If the episode has a failing then it's the idea that Jamie should make up the third member of the rocket crew. You can understand Radnor not wanting to risk losing Miss Kelly, but surely there should have been a T-Mat technician sent instead?
The idea that such a vital mission should be handed to three complete strangers, one of whom has no scientific knowledge whatsoever, is a bizarre one.
I'm not sure about taking the aliens' name so literally either. They aren't supposed to be made of ice...

Trivia
  • The ratings improve slightly, both in terms of viewer numbers and the appreciation score.
  • Competition from ITV came mainly from Irwin Allen productions, with some regions showing Land of the Giants and others Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea. The challenge to Doctor Who from these series was raised as a concern by Shaun Sutton at a weekly programme review meeting.
  • Tony Harwood had previously donned an Ice Warrior costume to play Rintan in The Ice Warriors.
  • Junior Points of View continued to cover letters from younger viewers begging Troughton to stay on as the Doctor. One possible replacement was suggested - Eric Porter, star of The Forsyte Saga. 
  • On the Thursday following broadcast of this episode, Television Today commented favourably on the scientific plausibility of the story, and the fact that a woman held such an important role and was so readily accepted by the male characters. Women rarely held positions of authority in TV drama at the time and, when they did, they would usually be patronised or subjected to outright sexism from colleagues.

Thursday, 19 November 2026

Inspirations: Twice Upon A Time


Feeling obliged to write a Christmas Special after Chris Chibnall stated that he was not ready to launch the Thirteenth Doctor until the Spring of 2018, Steven Moffat had to look at what festive elements had still to be used in the series - though he had already claimed that they had pretty much run out of the obvious Christmas trappings which might be exploited for a storyline.
The episode would have to tie up the Twelfth Doctor's story, and bring his own tenure as showrunner to a close. 
The groundwork for the regeneration had already been laid by having the Twelfth meet the First Doctor at the conclusion of The Doctor Falls, setting this in Antarctica during the latter stages of The Tenth Planet. Both were facing their regenerations, and both were stubbornly refusing to allow the process to go ahead. Over the course of events in this episode, each would help the other come to terms with what was about to happen.
It was noted that whenever previous incarnations of the Doctor met up they often clashed, which might allow for some humorous interplay between the pair.
Moffat was also thinking of the classic festive movie It's A Wonderful Life (1946) in which James Stewart plays a man who is given a chance to see what life would be like had he taken a certain course of action, and not unlike the future presented by the Ghost of Christmas-Yet-To-Come in Dickens' A Christmas Carol.

Looking at events in history set in the festive period, Moffat recalled the Christmas Truce during the first winter of the Great War. This event had been popularised by the video for Paul McCartney's 1983 song Pipes of Peace.
Moffat had been considering using it as the backdrop to a story for some time, but was wary of trivialising an incident from the Great War.
Famously, it had always been claimed through the Autumn and early Winter of 1914 that this conflict would be over by Christmas. In December of that year, the end was nowhere in sight.
Following the indecisive first Battle of Ypres, and the failure of the German "Race to the Sea" offensive, soldiers on both sides elected to cease hostilities for a short time. On Christmas Eve, it was agreed that bodies could be retrieved from No Man's Land for burial and prisoner swaps were arranged. In some cases football matches were organised and opposing armies mingled and ate together before singing Christmas carols.

Knowing that this was to be his last story in charge, Moffat wrote a part specifically for his Sherlock collaborator Mark Gatiss. He would play a British officer involved in the Christmas Truce, who would prove to be a forebear of Brigadier Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart, thus showing that that the Doctor had a greater role to play in the family which had come to mean so much to him. Gatiss would play the Brigadier's grandfather, Captain Archibald Hamish Lethbridge-Stewart.
He would find himself trapped in a foxhole with a wounded German soldier - and this allowed for the casting of another old friend of Moffat's - one who, like Gatiss, was also a writer. After writing School Reunion for RTD, Toby Whithouse had contributed six episodes throughout Moffat's tenure, most recently The Lie of the Land, and he was cast as the German soldier.
The Captain later states that he lives in Cromer in Norfolk - a reference to Nicholas Courtney's famous ad-libbed line in The Three Doctors.

The First Doctor we see here isn't quite the one as portrayed by William Hartnell. Rather, it is more of a caricature based partly on his character and that of Hartnell himself. For many years cast and crew had been generally positive about working with the actor - giving a sanitised version of their experience. 
But then Anneke Wills returned to the UK and began attending conventions. She was far more open about the negative experience she had of working with Hartnell, warts and all.
There's no real hint of the actor's racism here, though this is a more sexist and patronising version of the First Doctor. He is presented more as an old-fashioned fuddy-duddy.
At one point he threatens Bill with a jolly good smacked bottom - a First Doctor line to Susan from The Dalek Invasion of Earth.
David Bradley's iteration of the Doctor would be introduced by morphing his features over footage of Hartnell from The Tenth Planet's second episode.
Cut from the broadcast episode were more recreated scenes from The Tenth Planet, including a reprise for the Mondasian Cyberman costumes created for World Enough And Time / The Doctor Falls.
Ben and Polly feature - though the actor playing the former is rather too tall.
(These deleted scenes can be viewed on the DVD).
The first draft script had Ben and Polly later married and running a pub (as Michael Craze had really done) but RTD had already claimed they were running an orphanage in India in The Sarah Jane Adventures.

The enemy for the special - Testimony - would actually prove to be a benign entity, so for a genuine threat Moffat returned to "Rusty", the Dalek-hating Dalek introduced in Into The Dalek, right at the start of Capaldi's tenure. Daleks were usually outlawed from festive specials as they inevitably meant mass death and destruction, which isn't what families necessarily wanted served to them on Christmas evening. Rusty only really wanted to destroy other Daleks, however.
In showing the First Doctor what he later will become, clips from earlier stories were shown by Testimony, including Davros taunting the Tenth Doctor.
Rusty turns up on Villengard - a planet first mentioned in Moffat's very first story for Doctor Who. Its weapons forges are talked about in The Doctor Dances - Captain Jack saying that he got his squareness gun there, only for the Doctor to imply that he destroyed the factories as they are now covered in banana groves.
The Doctor seeks out Rusty in order to access its database and find out what Testimony actually is.
Testimony is said to have been founded on New Earth, a world first introduced in the story of that name in 2006 and revisited in Gridlock the following year.

As the story revolved around the act of witnessing, Moffat wanted someone to witness the Doctor's actions at the end of his current life, and decided that he wanted this to be Bill Potts. As Testimony could take on other people's likenesses, this allowed her to return since Bill had left behind her physical existence as a Cyberman at the end of The Doctor Falls to go travelling with Heather.
The final thing Moffat wanted to include was the Doctor regaining his memories of Clara, and Jenna Coleman was contacted whilst working on the second series of Victoria. She promised to make herself available, though it might only be for a couple of hours.
Matt Lucas would also return as Nardole for a final apearance.

The closing section was left for Chris Chibnall to write. He originally intended only for the new Doctor's POV to be seen until the very last moment, before she fell out of the TARDIS doors.
Capaldi's final scene was also the Twelfth Doctor's final scene. On the last day of shooting, Gatiss brought along to the studio the jacket which Jon Pertwee had worn in Planet of the Daleks, which Capaldi tried on. It was left on set in the background during the regeneration sequence.
Next time: The women who fall to Earth. The new Doctor encounters an alien who doesn't need to argue to go blue in the face...

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

R is for... Refusians


Invisible inhabitants of the planet Refusis II, they had lost their physical bodies in what they described as a "galactic explosion". They were aware that a vast spaceship was coming to their planet, bringing the human and Monoid survivors of the Earth's destruction to colonise their world. Unhappy in their present state, they longed to see the physical signs of life return, and had prepared structures in which the newcomers could live.
However, during the 700 year voyage, the Monoids had turned on the humans and enslaved them, and now planned to take the planet for themselves. The human population would be destroyed along with their spaceship, which had come to be known as the Ark.
The Refusians appear to have been humanoid in form themselves, and the one encountered by the Doctor was able to sit at a table and, later, inside a small travel capsule - the cushion of which depressed as it sat down. Despite this apparent size, they were capable of feats of prodigious strength - able to lift a gigantic stone statue and deposit it out of an airlock. The bomb intended to blow up the Ark was hidden inside it.
The same Refusian was able to destroy a capsule to prevent Monoid 2 warning the others still on the Ark.
The Monoids almost destroyed themselves in an internecine struggle, and the survivors were disarmed.
The Refusian stated that they still welcomed the newcomers - but only on the condition that they lived in peace with each other.

Voiced by Richard Beale. Appearances: The Ark (1966).
  • Richard Beale would feature in the programme - on screen this time - soon after, when he played Bat Masterson in The Gunfighters.
  • His voice was heard again in The Macra Terror, providing the propaganda announcements, and he later played the Ecology Minister in The Green Death.

R is for... Reegan


Reegan was a mercenary employed by General Carrington in his scheme to exact revenge on aliens whom he had encountered on Mars. Carrington had been an astronaut on a mission to the Red Planet, where he had seen his colleague Jim Daniels die through exposure to the beings they had met there. He kept this information to himself, until becoming head of security for the UK space programme. The aliens were going to swap the members of a second mission to Mars with their own kind, who were to act as ambassadors. Carrington's xenophobia led him to sabotage this by abducting the ambassadors and forcing to them to kill and steal, and thus provoke a hostile reaction to their coming. 
Reegan was employed to ensure that the aliens were held securely in an underground bunker, from which they could be sent out to kill - forced to do so as the radiation they needed to survive would be withheld from them should they disobey.
It was also Reegan's task to ensure that the authorities - including UNIT - could not discover the truth until Carrington's scheme was ready to be put into action. As such, he planted a bomb in the briefcase of Professor Taltalian, whose loyalty to the project was beginning to slip. Reegan also sabotaged the fuel supply to the rocket taking the Doctor into space to rendezvous with the alien spacecraft, and to then kidnap him on his return.
Prior to joining Carrington, Reegan had begun his criminal career as a bank robber, before becoming involved with terrorist groups.
He began to see the potential in keeping the alien ambassadors for himself - using them to steal for his own gain. He also disobeyed Carrington by not killing the Doctor as ordered - since he realised that he could help him communicate with the aliens.
He was arrested when UNIT stormed the bunker.

Played by William Dysart. Appearances: The Ambassadors of Death (1970)
  • Dysart had previously played Alexander McLaren in the opening episode of The Highlanders.
  • He featured in the final season of Terry Nations Survivors, and played Queen Victoria's ghillie John Brown in Edward the King - a drama about Edward VII.
  • The novelisation of this story states that Reegan had joined the IRA following his criminal career, but had to flee to America after pocketing loot intended for the organisation. This had been dropped from the TV series due to the increase in sectarian tensions in Northern Ireland at the time of production - and might help to explain his variable accent.

R is for... Redfern, Joan


A widow who worked as a nurse at Farringham School For Boys, she fell in love with a new teacher there named John Smith. 
The year was 1913. Joan had lost her husband during the Second Boer War, at the Battle of Spion Kop in 1900.
She was unaware that Smith was the Doctor, who had employed a Chameleon Arch to rewrite his biology to make himself human - a process which also suppressed his memory of his true nature. He was being hunted by ruthless aliens known as the Family of Blood, who took over the bodies of others to survive and sought a Time Lord body for their son.
Despite now being a somewhat shy and reserved academic, Smith began to reciprocate the feelings she felt for him, which greatly alarmed the Doctor's companion Martha Jones. She had secured a role as a servant at the school in order to watch over him - and harboured romantic feelings towards him herself.
At times Nurse Redfern felt she had to put the servant in her place, but was surprised that Martha had equal medical knowledge to her own.
Smith told Joan about recurring dreams he had of travelling across the stars and meeting alien beings, which he wrote down in a journal.
The Family suspected that Smith had knowledge of the Doctor and began to stalk him - attacking a village dance which he and Joan attended. They then launched an attack on the school.
Eventually, Joan learned of Smith's true nature from Martha. She then rejected him - blaming the Doctor for having brought death and destruction to this community even though - as Smith - he had never intended this to happen. Once he had defeated the Family and reverted to being the Doctor again, he did ask her to join him in the TARDIS, but she declined after it become clear that he would not become John Smith again. It was he whom she had fallen in love with - not the Doctor.
She kept the journal and, many years later, it was found by her grand-daughter Verity Newman who published Joan's story as The Journal of Impossible Things. Verity had been named after Smith's supposed mother. The Doctor sought her out at a book signing as he faced his imminent regeneration, seeking confirmation that Joan had lived a happy life after what he had put her through.

Played by Jessica Hynes. Appearances: Human Nature / The Family of Blood (2007).
  • Under her maiden name of Stevenson, Hynes had made her breakthrough with a number of collaborations with Simon Pegg - most notably Spaced, which she co-wrote, and the movie Shaun of the Dead.
  • She has also featured in the Bridget Jones and Paddington movie franchises.
  • In 2012 she was reunited with David Tennant in the second Nativity! film, and in 2019 appeared in RTD's Years and Years.
  • She returned to Doctor Who to play Verity Newman in The End of Time Part II.
  • In Paul Cornell's original Seventh Doctor novel, Joan Redfern is a 48 year old science teacher at Hulton College.

R is for... Red & Yellow Robots


One morning, Clyde Langer and Rani Chandra woke up to find they were the only people left on planet Earth. They set off for the city to try to find others, and encountered a pair of huge bipedal robots - one red, the other yellow - which claimed to have come for the sun and the air.
A short time later, they came across one other person - a schoolboy named Gavin. It became apparent that the robots were looking for him. Clyde and Rani traced him to a block of flats where he lived in an unhappy relationship with an aunt and uncle.
It soon transpired that he was actually an alien prince, sent to Earth by his parents as a place of safety. They were now dead and the political situation on his planet had improved, so the robots had come to Earth to locate him and bring him home so that he could assume the throne of his homeworld. 
What the robots had really been seeking was "the son and the heir". They had temporarily removed the world's population in order to identify him.
After they had departed from Earth with Gavin, everyone was returned, with no memory of ever having been away though faced with lost time. 
Sarah Jane Smith explained to Clyde and Rani that the reason they had been left behind was because they had been "grounded" by the Judoon - forbidden from leaving Earth - so the robots could not legally remove them.

Played by Paul Kasey (Red Robot), Ruari Mears (Yellow Robot), voiced by Jon Glover. 
Appearances: SJA 4.4 The Empty Planet (2010).

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Episode 232: The Seeds of Death (1)


Synopsis:
Earth has abandoned conventional modes of transport and is no longer interested in space travel. Instead, it relies totally on T-Mat - a form of instantaneous travel utilising matter transmission. People simply step into a T-Mat cubicle and are transported to their destination, and goods are sent around the globe in the same way.
The system is operated from a central control complex near London, connected to regional centres in cities across the planet. A vital relay station is located in a base on the Moon.
Recently there have been a number of problems with the system, which appear to emanate from operations on Moonbase. Controller Gia Kelly arranges for senior technician Osgood to travel there to sort out the issues. She blames these on a new assistant controller named Fewsham, whom Osgood had recommended for promotion but who she believes isn't up to the task.
Her superior, Commander Julian Radnor, arrives at T-Mat Control soon after Osgood has departed for the Moon with some assistants. Miss Kelly assures him that everything is under control.
Shortly after Osgood arrives on the Moon, an alarm sounds to indicate that an external airlock door has been opened - though no-one is scheduled to be outside the base.
Technicians Phipps and Locke rush in, terrified at what they have just seen. Alien figures appear at the entrance to the control room, and another technician named Harvey is shot dead when he panics and tries to flee.
At T-Mat Control, assistant controller Brent informs Kelly that the system has come to a halt. She tries to contact the Moonbase by video-link.
Osgood at first refuses to obey the instructions of the alien arrivals. Then, when he pretends to help, he sabotages some controls - only to pay with his life.
Radnor demands to know what is going on, and Kelly reports the loss of video-link with the Moon.
The TARDIS materialises and, on operating the scanner, the Doctor and his companions initially think that they have materialised in space when they see a Cosmonaut appear on the screen. When the Doctor adjusts the scanner, they discover that they are actually in a museum dedicated to space travel and so venture outside. Looking around, Zoe activates a video display which gives a presentation on T-Mat.
As it comes to an end, they suddenly find themselves confronted by an elderly man, armed with a laser pistol.
Fewsham tells Slaar, the leader of the aliens, that he is unable to repair T-Mat or the video-link. They will need the services of Miss Kelly. On being threatened with death if they cannot help, Fewsham explains that there is an emergency link to Earth, which is less damaged. He and the others are ordered to fix it and Slaar withdraws, leaving a guard outside the door.
Phipps and Locke are resistant to helping the aliens, but Fewsham is too scared to disobey.
Radnor is informed by Kelly and Brent that the problem with T-Mat can definitely be traced to Moonbase, which they are unable to contact. The only way of getting there would be by conventional means - a rocket. When Brent mentions that such things are only to be found in a museum these days, Radnor has an idea...
The Doctor and his companions have discovered that they are in the workshop of Professor Daniel Eldred, which he has turned into a private museum now that space travel is a thing of the past. He had been a pioneer in rocketry, like his father before him. 
The Doctor wins him over by showing great enthusiasm for his displays and agreeing with his views about the short-sightedness of abandoning conventional travel means. Eldred blames T-Mat for putting a stop to his work - but he hints that he is still carrying on with something by himself.
On Moonbase, Locke and Phipps are trying to repair the video-link so that they can warn Earth.
Radnor turns up at the museum with Miss Kelly. He was once a close colleague of Eldred's, but abandoned him to join the T-Mat project. He tells the professor that the authorities have been aware for some that he has been secretly preparing a rocket for flight. He explains the problems at T-Mat Control and asks to know how advanced Eldred is with his spacecraft. He wants to use it to get a repair team up to Moonbase. A message is passed on from T-Mat Control that food shortages are already occurring.
Eldred explains that his rocket - ZA-685 - is nowhere near ready, but the Doctor and Miss Kelly offer to help and Radnor promises unlimited resources as well. Grudgingly, the old man accepts - seeing the irony in an old-fashioned rocket having to come to T-Mat's assistance.
Locke has repaired the communications link with Earth, though audio only. He manages to report that they are in desperate trouble and that Osgood is dead - before the equipment is pulled away by a clamp-like hand.
Slaar has returned to the control room. He summons a guard and orders Locke killed.
An Ice Warrior enters, and shoots the technician dead...

Data:
Written by Brian Hayles
Recorded: Friday 3rd January 1969 - Lime Grove Studio D
First broadcast: 5.15pm, Saturday 25th January 1969
Ratings: 6.6 million / AI 57
VFX: Bill King & Trading Post
Designer: Paul Allen
Director: Michael Ferguson
Guest cast: Louise Pajo (Gia Kelly), Ronald Leigh-Hunt (Radnor), Philip Ray (Eldred), Terry Scully (Fewsham), Harry Towb (Osgood), Ric Felgate (Brent), Christopher Coll (Phipps), Martin Cort (Locke), Alan Bennion (Slaar), Steve Peters (Ice Warrior), John Witty (Computer Voice)


Critique:
As The Ice Warriors had proved popular, Brian Hayles began working on another story featuring his creations. This was titled "The Lords of the Red Planet" and was set on Mars, in the city of Gandor. Martian society was composed of the ruling Gandorians and the Saurians, who were a slave-race. Gandorians were humanoid in appearance but with reptilian scales on their faces. Their monarch was Queen Veltrena who was fully human-like - genetically engineered by a scientist named Quendril. Only he and a warlord named Zaadur knew this. The Gandorians were a dying race, unable to reproduce, and Quendril was experimenting with rejuvenation techniques to save them, whilst Zaadur wanted to colonise other worlds. Exploratory missions to other planets had been sent out - one of which had been Varga's. Because they were humanoid, the Doctor and his companions were treated favourably at first by the Gandorians, but soon got involved in the political in-fighting which developed between factions loyal to Quendril and Zaadur. The Saurians were being bio-engineered to become Ice Warriors, and the Doctor befriended one named Vargason, who eventually sacrificed himself to defeat Zaadur.
At this stage it wasn't known who the new female companion would be, so Hayles dubbed her "Dolly" as a placeholder name.
The story went through a number of drafts, which added other characters into the mix and made the Queen Quendril's daughter, and Jamie at one point was to have found himself her pet. The Gandorian / Saurian element was dropped.

Hayles was paid for his story outline, but it was decided not to develop it any further. 
Having just taken over as Script Editor, Terrance Dicks then approached Hayles for a different Ice Warrior story, to be titled "The Seeds of Death".
This was set on the Earth and Moon of 3000 AD. It opened with the Ice Warriors already in control of the Moonbase, with Fewsham being ordered to send Warriors to Earth by T-Mat to plant Martian spores. These would germinate four weeks later and prevent plants from producing chlorophyll through a hereditary virus. There were two Martian warlords on the Moon, described as more intelligent and more humanoid than the Warriors previously seen. Slaar appeared first, but was then joined in the second episode by his superior Visek. It was Dicks who had suggested the warlords, in order to make the Ice Warriors more interesting as characters.
Eldred was an eccentric space museum owner, and the rocket piloted by the Doctor and his companions was one of his exhibits. The TARDIS landed on the launch pad of his museum, and he knocked out the travellers with a gas-gun and tied them up, rather than simply point his weapon at them.
Miss Kelly was a male character, who was assisted by a female PR officer named Mary Burcott.
Hayles was initially asked to include the new male companion Nik, who was to be introduced in the previous story - "The Prison in Space". Later, he would be told to change this to Jamie, then back to Nik, then back to Jamie again. He also had to incorporate a holiday for Patrick Troughton and have the Doctor absent from Episode Four.

As scripts arrived, Dicks and Derrick Sherwin became increasingly worried that it wasn't turning out as they hoped. There were also concerns about the number of sets required, and the amount of filming suggested. Adding to this his late delivery of scripts for the second half of the story, Dicks stepped in to restructure the whole story, whilst retaining elements of Hayles' work on the first two instalments only. 
He was paid for these, along with some rewrite fees for later instalments, but otherwise the story was taken out of his hands. Through his agent Hayles complained of the last minute changes he had been asked to make, but Dicks argued successfully that he had been briefed in good time.
Feeling bad about how the writer had been treated, Dicks did contact him and was pleased to hear that he bore no ill feeling about events - and the pair would work together again in the 1970's on the Peladon stories (though Dicks would have to heavily rework the second of these).
In his new scripts, Dicks wanted to hold back the appearance of the monsters to the cliff-hanger, so stage directions had characters looking directly into camera whilst the actor playing Slaar was to remain just out of sight. Fans would be able to guess the villains from the mirror distortion effect and sound their weapons made as they killed people.
Dicks decided not to mention any date on screen though the Doctor recognises an ion jet rocket model in the museum as being from the 21st Century.
Eldred was to have stated that this was the rocket which first put men on the Moon - but this line was dropped when it was realised that NASA might get there in the very near future.


The only filming required for this opening episode was the model work undertaken at Ealing on Friday 13th December. This was for shots of the Earth and Moon which would be used as part of the title sequence.
Initially it had been planned that the BBC VFX team would handle the effects, but they were understaffed at this time and, because of the extensive effects needed for the story, it was decided instead to contract the work out to Bill King's company.
Two versions of the Earth / Moon shot were filmed - one with the Earth in the foreground and the other with the Moon in this position. Which version was used depended on the setting for the opening scene of each episode.
On Monday 23rd December, a single shot was taken of an Ice Warrior firing its gun, which would be used as an insert throughout the story.

The main guest artist was Ronald Leigh-Hunt who had been working on Freewheelers since 1968, and who was well known to audiences for playing King Arthur in The Adventures of Sir Lancelot, which had starred William Russell. All of the cast were actors who had worked with director Michael Ferguson before on other productions. He had directed Alan Bennion in a tour of Oliver Twist, for instance. Terry Scully was a friend whom he had directed in Z-Cars, and Philip Ray had been a regular on soap The Newcomers, several episodes of which Ferguson had worked on.
The director liked to have a fun-run during rehearsals where the cast ran through the script as quickly as possible whilst doing silly voices or accents.
Costumes were handled by Bobi Bartlett, and make-up by Sylvia James, whilst designer Peter Allen was new to the programme.
Dudley Simpson once more provided the incidental music, having already established a drumbeat theme for the Ice Warriors for their debut. His compositions were then enhanced with radiophonic effects from Brian Hodgson.
We'll discuss the Ice Warriors and Slaar next time, when they make their appearance proper.

The first episode would use only three main sets, apart from the TARDIS console room of which we only see a corner comprising two walls, one of which is the photographic one, and the console. The new sets were T-Mat Control Earth, Moonbase Control, and Eldred's space museum. The latter was dressed with a number of props, some of which had featured in the series before such as the Doctor's Astral Map, the Dominator drill and part of the Gravitron.
During afternoon rehearsals on the first studio day, publicity photographs were taken of Slaar, an Ice Warrior, Osgood and Fewsham, Miss Kelly and Radnor.
The regulars retained their costumes from The Krotons, Padbury's PVC-paper outfit having been repaired since its last outing. 
Recording ran from 8.30 - 10pm, and began with the opening captions playing over the Moon / Earth model shot. 
A locked-off camera was used to show people disappearing and reappearing in the T-Mat cubicles. Stuntman Alan Chuntz played the unlucky technician Harvey. As with The Ice Warriors, the deaths were recorded by having the camera point at a reflection of the actor on a piece of flexible Mirrorlon, which was then prodded from behind to produce the rippling distortion effect. Harvey's death was recorded out of sequence at the end of this scene.
A number of images from various photographic agencies were used to show some of the exhibits in Eldred's museum, such as Leonardo Da Vinci's drawing.
Photo captions had also been prepared showing the T-Mat capsule superimposed over photographs of Westminster Bridge, Trafalgar Square and Parliament Street, to be shown as part of the T-Mat presentation video.
John Witty, who was providing the computer voice, also narrated this video. He was an announcer as well as an actor.
Alan Bennion was given a radio mike for his dialogue, and Ferguson used POV shots for the people he was addressing to conceal Slaar's appearance until the climax.


"Hey, look at the size of this one, Doctor"
"Yes, my word, Jamie, look at that... Very large"
It's not quite the "Would you look at the size of that one, Doctor..." / "Yes, that is a big one..." we'll get later but, when it comes to double-entendres, Troughton and Hines did like to slip one in...
It is noticeable that the Doctor and his companions take a very long time to get into the story, and then only feature in a few scenes on the same set once they do. It's also the shortest episode of the six, so we can clearly see Troughton's desire for a reduced workload being granted this week.
Michael Ferguson liked to experiment visually, and we will see this throughout the story. Characters are sometimes framed through bits of set, and we have a lot of over-the-shoulder shots as well as figures with their back to camera, facing the characters who we are supposed to be listening to.
Of those characters, Fewsham is clearly the most interesting. We learn a lot about him in just this episode. He has only recently been promoted but is clearly out of his depth, as there are problems with T-Mat before the Ice Warriors turn up. Gia Kelly obviously doesn't rate him, and it was on Osgood's recommendation that he was given the task - which is presumably why it is he who is being sent to sort things out.
He's made out to be cowardly, but then he has just seen his chief supporter gunned down, followed by technician Harvey. (As soon as you see these stunt guys, you're just waiting for them to go flying across the room or take a fall).
The other main characters are more stereotypes - the ice maiden, the eccentric professor and the no-nonsense, military commander. The young woman is, however, in a position of authority and has great technical skill.

The audience of the day would have been bemused by the idea of Earth having abandoned space travel, as the space race was big news at the time. This story was broadcast during the Apollo missions, between Apollo's 8 and 9. Astronauts would set foot on the Moon for the first time later that year.

The Seeds of Death is widely considered the best of the Ice Warrior stories of the classic era. This is mainly because we have more of them and they have a lot more to do, and because they now have a spokesperson leading them in the form of Slaar. (We'll call him an Ice Lord, as this is what fandom has dubbed this officer class of Martian).
As well as their debut being a popular story, a return for the Ice Warriors was inevitable as the costumes had been very expensive to produce, and money was tight this season. Indeed, this will be the final story of the 1960's to feature monsters, thanks to the cost of creating them. After this there will be three months of purely humanoid villainy.

Trivia:
  • The ratings get off to a very slow start. This episode will have the weakest viewing figure of the whole story.
  • As mentioned above, this is also the shortest of the six episodes, running to 23' 11".
  • Ronald Leigh-Hunt would soon be reunited with Wendy Padbury on the Southern Television adventure series Freewheelers. He returned to Doctor Who in 1975 to play Commander Stevenson in Revenge of the Cybermen.
  • Christopher Coll will be back as Skybase One guard Stubbs in The Mutants.
  • Harry Towb will later play McDermott, who is memorably suffocated by a plastic chair in Terror of the Autons.
  • Martin Cort had featured in a number of roles in The Keys of Marinus, most notably playing Aydan. He was also a Voord, and the mechanical knight in The Screaming Jungle.
  • Ric Felgate was the director's brother-in-law. Ferguson had previously employed him as journalist Roy Stone in The War Machines, and will later cast him as astronaut Van Lyden in The Ambassadors of Death.
  • Steve Peters was billed simply as "Alien" in Radio Times, to conceal the return of the Ice Warriors. A background artist in The Romans, he would be used by Ferguson again as one of The Ambassadors of Death, as well as featuring as a space pirate in the very next story.
  • Radio Times once again opted not to include any special feature on the new story, simply including a small photo of Troughton (from The Power of the Daleks) to illustrate the opening episode on the daily listings page. We'll be seeing similar images a lot in RT over the next few months.
  • However, the issue dated 3rd October 1968, covering the Midlands region, had included a significant profile piece on Hayles to promote a play of his, in which he stated that he had been working on a new Doctor Who story.